Why Your Emails Going to Spam and How to Fix It

blog_related_media

blog_topic

blog_related_activities

blog_niche

blog_related_tips

unique_blog_element

It’s one of the most maddening experiences for any marketer. You’ve poured hours into crafting the perfect email, hit "send" with high hopes, and... nothing. It just disappears into the spam folder, never to be seen.

The real culprit behind your emails going to spam usually isn't just a few spammy keywords. It's almost always your sender reputation—a hidden score that email providers like Gmail and Outlook assign to your domain based on your sending habits. Improving it means looking at everything: your technical setup, your content, and the health of your email list.

Why Your Emails Go to Spam

It’s easy to think spam filters have a personal vendetta against you, but they’re just trying to protect users from an overwhelming flood of junk. And the scale of that flood is mind-boggling. Spam messages account for a staggering 45% of all daily emails sent worldwide. That’s about 14.5 billion spam emails every single day.

The financial toll is just as shocking, with businesses losing an estimated $20.5 billion a year to spam-related issues. You can dig into more of these eye-opening email spam statistics and their impact to see the full picture.

This sheer volume is why inbox providers rely on sophisticated algorithms to vet every single message. They've moved far beyond simply scanning for suspicious words; now, they analyze your entire sending profile to decide if you belong in the inbox.

Your Sender Reputation is Everything

Think of your sender reputation as a credit score for your email domain. It's an invisible grade that tells mailbox providers whether you're trustworthy. Every single email you send, and every action a recipient takes, nudges this score up or down.

A bad reputation is the single biggest reason legitimate emails get flagged as spam. It’s not just one thing, but a combination of signals that paint a picture of who you are as a sender.

Here’s what typically tanks a sender score:

Authentication Failures: Missing key technical records like SPF or DKIM is a huge red flag. It’s like showing up to the airport without an ID.

High Complaint Rates: If people are constantly hitting the "spam" button on your emails, your reputation will plummet. Fast.

Lousy Engagement: Consistently low open and click-through rates tell inbox providers that your audience isn't interested in what you have to say.

Poor List Quality: Sending emails to outdated, invalid, or inactive addresses leads to high bounce rates, which is a classic sign of a spammer.

It's not that spam filters are overly aggressive; it’s that many well-meaning senders simply haven't built enough trust. The name of the game is sending consistent, positive signals that prove your emails are valuable and, most importantly, wanted.

It’s More Than Just Keywords

While you should still avoid overly salesy phrases and deceptive subject lines, modern filters are much smarter than that. They're looking at the bigger picture.

For example, sending a brilliantly written email from a brand-new domain that hasn't been properly "warmed up" looks exactly like what a spammer would do. Even something as innocent as using a URL shortener or certain tracking pixels can sometimes get flagged by cautious filters, even if your intentions are pure.

In this guide, we'll walk through the technical fixes, content tweaks, and list management habits that are hurting your deliverability. I'll give you clear, practical steps to build a rock-solid sender reputation and make sure your messages land where they belong: in front of your audience.

2. Run a Technical Health Check for Better Deliverability

Before you touch a single word of your email copy, we need to look under the hood. More often than not, when your emails land in spam, it's because the big inbox providers (think Gmail, Outlook) can't technically verify that you are who you say you are.

This isn't about your witty subject line; it's about your digital identity.

Getting these technical signals right is the bedrock of good deliverability. I like to think of it as a passport for your emails—without it, you’re not getting past the border guards. This is where email authentication enters the picture.

What Is Email Authentication, Really?

Email authentication is just a set of technical handshakes that prove your emails are legitimate. These protocols protect your domain from being used by spammers and phishers, which in turn builds a huge amount of trust with mailbox providers.

The three key players you'll hear about constantly are SPF, DKIM, and DMARC.

Sender Policy Framework (SPF): This is basically a public list of all the servers authorized to send email on behalf of your domain. It’s you telling the world, "Hey, if you get an email from mydomain.com, it should only come from these specific servers."

DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM): DKIM acts like a tamper-proof seal on a package. It adds a unique digital signature to every email you send, which the receiving server checks to make sure the message hasn't been altered along the way.

Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance (DMARC): Think of DMARC as the bouncer. It stands on the shoulders of SPF and DKIM and tells receiving servers what to do if an email fails those checks—either stick it in the spam folder or reject it completely. It also sends you reports on who’s trying to send mail from your domain.

Setting up these three records is non-negotiable for anyone serious about email marketing. From my experience, it's the single most powerful technical step you can take to keep your emails out of the spam folder.

Let's break down what each of these records does and why it's so important for staying on the good side of spam filters.

Email Authentication Health Check

Authentication Record	Primary Function	Why It Matters for Spam Filters
SPF	Lists authorized sending servers for your domain.	Confirms the email came from a permitted source. A "fail" looks like a potential impersonation.
DKIM	Adds a digital signature to verify the email's integrity.	Proves the message wasn't tampered with in transit. A missing signature is a major red flag.
DMARC	Instructs servers on how to handle SPF/DKIM failures.	Gives you control and insight. A proper DMARC policy shows you're actively managing your domain's security.

Getting a 'pass' on all three tells inbox providers that you're a legitimate sender who takes security seriously, giving your emails a much better shot at landing in the inbox.

How to Check Your Current Setup

You don't have to be a tech wizard to see if your domain is properly authenticated.

There are several great free tools out there that can run a quick diagnostic. I often point people to MXToolbox or Dmarcian. You just plug in your domain name, and they'll spit out a report showing if your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are valid and correctly configured.

This image below gives you a glimpse into what a DKIM signature actually looks like in an email's technical header. It's this block of code that servers use for verification.

That highlighted signature is the "digital fingerprint" that proves the message is authentic. If these records are missing or broken, it's an immediate red flag for spam filters.

If you find any issues, don't panic. Your email service provider—whether it's Mailchimp, ConvertKit, or HubSpot—will have step-by-step guides on how to add the correct records to your domain's DNS settings. It’s usually just a matter of copying and pasting a few lines of text.

For a deeper dive into the setup and ongoing maintenance, our guide on email deliverability best practices is a great resource.

Beyond Authentication: Your Domain and IP Reputation

While authentication is the critical first step, inbox providers are also keeping a running score on your sending domain and the IP address it uses.

Your domain's reputation is built over time, influenced by your sending volume, how much users engage with your emails, and how many people mark you as spam. A brand-new domain has zero reputation, which can actually look suspicious to filters.

This is why you always hear about "warming up" a new domain. You start by sending small batches of emails to your most engaged subscribers and slowly increase the volume. It's all about building that trust one send at a time.

Your IP reputation matters, too. Most people start on a shared IP, which is an IP address used by many different customers of an email provider. They're cost-effective, but the catch is that your reputation can be dinged by someone else's bad sending habits.

Larger senders might eventually move to a dedicated IP, giving them total control over their own reputation. But with great power comes great responsibility—you're the only one responsible for building and protecting it. For most businesses, a shared IP from a top-tier provider is the way to go.

Writing Emails That Actually Land in the Inbox

Once you’ve got your technical house in order, the real work begins: the content of your emails. Spam filters have come a long way from just flagging certain keywords. Today, they're sophisticated algorithms that analyze the substance, structure, and intent of your message.

The tricky part is that many common marketing practices, even with the best intentions, can accidentally set off alarms.

It's all about striking a balance. You need to write for your audience first, but you also have to be aware of what the algorithms are looking for. We're moving beyond the outdated advice of just avoiding "FREE" in all caps. Let's dig into the subtle content triggers that are a common cause of emails going to spam.

Craft a Subject Line That Builds Trust

Your subject line is your first impression, and it’s read by both your subscriber and the spam filter. If it looks deceptive or overly aggressive, you’re on a fast track to the junk folder. The goal is to be intriguing, not misleading.

Put yourself in the recipient's shoes. A subject line that starts with "Re:" or "Fwd:" to fake an ongoing conversation is a classic spammer tactic and an immediate red flag. The same goes for shouting in ALL-CAPS, using excessive punctuation (!!!), or swapping letters for weird symbols.

Instead, prioritize clarity and relevance. We have a whole guide on writing the perfect newsletter subject line that’s packed with great examples of how to be creative without getting flagged. A solid subject line gives a clear idea of what’s inside while sparking genuine curiosity.

Keep Your Content Balanced

Have you ever received an email that's just one giant image? Spam filters hate that. It’s a common trick spammers use to hide shady text and links from being scanned, so an email with tons of imagery and very little text can trigger those filters instantly.

A good rule of thumb is to maintain a healthy text-to-image ratio. While there isn't a single magic number, try to make sure your email is at least 60% text. This tells inbox providers that you're communicating a real message, not just trying to slip past them with a pretty picture.

Pro Tip: Always fill out the alt text for your images. It's not just great for accessibility (which it is!); it also gives spam filters more context about your email's content. They see this as a positive signal that you’re being transparent.

This balance shows you’re focused on providing actual value through your words, not just flashy visuals. It makes your email easier to read and far less likely to be flagged.

Your Links Matter More Than You Think

Every single link in your email is under scrutiny. Spam filters check the reputation of every domain you point to, and using sketchy-looking URLs will tank your deliverability.

Here are a few linking best practices to live by:

Ditch the URL Shorteners: Services like Bitly or TinyURL are frequently used by spammers to disguise malicious destinations. Always use the full, original URL so filters can see exactly where you're sending people.

Link to Reputable Sites: Make sure every outbound link goes to a secure, trustworthy website. Linking to a site with a poor reputation can drag yours down with it.

Keep Your HTML Clean: Broken or sloppy HTML code can look suspicious to an algorithm. Ensure your email templates are clean and well-structured, especially around your links.

This attention to detail is more important than ever because of phishing, a particularly nasty subset of spam. With an estimated 3.4 billion phishing emails sent every single day, inbox providers are on high alert. Scammers use deceptive links to steal personal information, and filters are trained to spot any linking behavior that looks even remotely similar. You can read up on the latest phishing trends and how to stay safe to get a better sense of the threat.

Ultimately, by writing clean, transparent, and valuable content, you send all the right signals—both to your audience and to the algorithms guarding their inboxes.

Improve Deliverability with Smart List Management

Who you send emails to is just as important as what’s inside them. In fact, it might be more important. A messy, low-quality email list is one of the fastest ways to tank your sender reputation and get your messages dumped straight into the spam folder.

Think about it from the perspective of an inbox provider like Gmail or Outlook. When you send to a clean, engaged list, they see high open rates, low bounces, and minimal spam complaints. Those are all powerful signals that people want your emails. But if you neglect your list? You’ll see the opposite: high bounce rates and spam reports, which practically screams "spammer" to their algorithms.

Build Your List the Right Way

I’ve seen it countless times: a business gets impatient and looks for a shortcut to grow its audience. Let me be crystal clear about the biggest mistake you can make: never, ever buy an email list. It might seem like a quick win, but you're actually paying for a one-way ticket to the spam folder.

Purchased lists are a minefield of problems waiting to happen.

Spam Traps: These are email addresses set up by inbox providers specifically to catch marketers who use shady list-building tactics. Hitting just one can get your domain or IP blacklisted.

Zero Engagement: The people on these lists never asked to hear from you. The best you can hope for is that they ignore you. More likely, they’ll report you as spam, which is a direct hit to your reputation.

Sky-High Bounce Rates: So many addresses on purchased lists are old, fake, or simply abandoned. A high hard bounce rate is another major red flag for providers, telling them you have no idea who you're contacting.

The only way to build a list that actually delivers results is to do it organically. You want people who choose to hear from you. This is where a double opt-in process is your best friend.

A double opt-in simply asks new subscribers to click a link in a confirmation email to verify their address. It adds one tiny step for them but gives you a list full of real, engaged people who genuinely want your content. It’s a simple change that works wonders for reducing bounces and spam complaints.

For more hands-on strategies, our guide on how to build an email list from scratch is a fantastic starting point.

Prune Your List with a Sunset Policy

Look, not every subscriber will stay engaged forever. People’s interests change, they switch jobs, or they just get busy. That's totally normal. What’s not normal is continuing to send emails to people who haven't opened one in months.

Hanging onto inactive subscribers actually hurts you. It drags down your open rates and tells inbox providers that your content isn't hitting the mark. This is where a sunset policy becomes essential.

A sunset policy is just a formal way of saying you have a system for cleaning out inactive contacts. It keeps your list healthy and your engagement metrics looking sharp.

Here's how I typically recommend setting one up:

First, you need to decide what "inactive" means for you. For many businesses, it’s someone who hasn't opened an email in the last 90 or 180 days.

Next, before you just delete them, try to win them back. A re-engagement campaign can work wonders. This is usually a short series of emails with a punchy subject line like "Is this goodbye?" or "Still want to hear from us?" You can offer a special discount, show them what they've missed, or just flat-out ask them to confirm they want to stay.

If they still don't engage after that campaign, it's time to say a graceful goodbye and remove them. Don't think of it as losing a subscriber; think of it as focusing your energy on the audience that truly values what you have to say.

Finally, remember that smart list management is also about respecting privacy. Ensuring your practices align with guidelines like GDPR compliance for email marketing is non-negotiable. It builds trust and reinforces your credibility. By regularly cleaning your list and prioritizing quality over sheer quantity, you'll see a massive improvement in your sender reputation and keep your emails right where they belong: the inbox.

Building a Strong Sender Reputation Over Time

Your sender reputation isn't something you can fix with a single technical tweak. It's earned over a long period through consistent, positive sending habits. Inbox providers are always watching, and they reward senders who prove they're trustworthy and predictable.

Think of it like building a friendship. You wouldn’t meet someone for the first time and immediately ask for a huge favor. You build trust slowly, interaction by interaction. Your email domain works the exact same way. Playing the long game is how you ensure the problem of emails going to spam becomes a thing of the past.

The Crucial Art of the Warm-Up

If you’re starting with a brand-new domain or a fresh dedicated IP, you have zero reputation. Blasting out 50,000 emails on day one is the digital equivalent of a stranger shouting in a quiet library—it's alarming, and you'll get shut down fast.

This is where the "warm-up" process becomes non-negotiable.

The whole point is to gradually introduce yourself to inbox providers like Gmail and Outlook. You have to start small and slowly ramp up your sending volume, proving along the way that you’re a legitimate sender whose emails are actually wanted.

A typical warm-up schedule might look something like this:

Week 1: Send just 100-200 emails per day, and only to your most engaged subscribers (people who've opened or clicked recently).

Week 2: Bump it up to 400-500 emails per day. You can expand the audience slightly, but keep the focus on active contacts.

Week 3: Double the volume again to around 1,000 per day, keeping a close eye on your engagement metrics.

Week 4 and beyond: Continue doubling your volume weekly, but only if your open rates stay high and complaint rates remain rock-bottom.

This methodical approach builds a positive history and teaches the algorithms that you're a sender to be trusted. Rushing this process is one of the most common and damaging mistakes a new sender can make.

Consistency Beats Intensity

Inbox providers love predictability. A sender who sends 5,000 emails every Tuesday looks far more legitimate than someone who sends nothing for three weeks and then blasts out 100,000 emails in a single afternoon.

Why? Because erratic sending patterns mimic the exact behavior of spammers who buy a list and try to hit it as hard as they can before getting blacklisted.

Find a regular cadence that works for your audience and stick to it. Whether it's daily, weekly, or bi-weekly, a consistent schedule helps build a recognizable sending pattern. This rhythm makes your email traffic look stable and far less threatening to spam filters.

Monitor Your Key Reputation Metrics

You can't improve what you don't measure. Keeping a close eye on your deliverability metrics is essential for spotting problems before they spiral out of control. These numbers tell the real story of how recipients—and their email providers—perceive your messages.

Pay close attention to these vital signs:

Complaint Rate: This is the percentage of people who hit the "spam" button on your email. Anything above 0.1% (that’s just 1 complaint per 1,000 emails) is a major warning sign.

Bounce Rate: Specifically, watch your hard bounce rate. A high number suggests your list is old or poor quality. A healthy hard bounce rate should stay well under 2%.

Engagement Rates: Low open and click-through rates tell inbox providers that your content isn't resonating. Over time, this can cause them to filter your messages more aggressively.

The digital mailroom is an incredibly crowded place. Spam makes up roughly 46% of all global email traffic, which works out to about 160 billion spam emails sent daily. With the U.S. and China leading the charge, inbox providers have no choice but to be strict. You can explore more fascinating data in these in-depth spam statistics to understand the scale of the challenge.

Ultimately, building a strong sender reputation is an ongoing commitment. It demands patience, consistency, and a deep respect for your audience's inbox. By warming up your domain properly, maintaining a steady sending schedule, and monitoring your key metrics, you establish the trust needed to secure your place in the inbox for the long haul.

Common Questions About Email Deliverability

Even after you’ve ticked all the boxes—authentication, content, list hygiene—you’re bound to have some lingering questions. Email deliverability isn’t a one-and-done task; it’s an ongoing process. Let’s dig into some of the most frequent questions we hear from people trying to keep their emails out of the spam folder.

Is a Dedicated IP Address Better Than a Shared One?

This is one of the oldest debates in email, and the honest answer is: it depends entirely on you.

Think of a shared IP like living in an apartment building. You're sharing the building's address (the IP) with other tenants (senders). For the most part, this is great. It's affordable, and the landlord (your email provider) takes care of maintenance and keeps the building's reputation clean. The only risk is a "noisy neighbor"—a bad sender on your IP who could briefly cause problems for everyone.

A dedicated IP is like owning your own house. You have total control over the reputation of your address, but you're also responsible for all the upkeep. It’s a fantastic option for high-volume senders—we’re talking over 100,000 emails a month—who have their sending practices completely locked down. For almost everyone else, a reputable shared IP is the smarter, safer bet.

How Long Does It Take to Fix a Bad Sender Reputation?

If you’re looking for a quick fix, I have some bad news. Rebuilding a damaged sender reputation is a marathon, not a sprint. The timeline really depends on how deep a hole you're in and how committed you are to digging yourself out.

For minor slip-ups, like a single campaign with a high bounce rate, you could see positive changes within a couple of weeks of consistent, clean sending. But if your domain has been blacklisted or has a long history of generating spam complaints, you should be prepared for a three to six-month journey to fully regain the trust of inbox providers.

Consistency is everything. You need to show the mailbox provider algorithms that you’ve changed your ways for good, and that kind of proof takes time.

Do Emojis in Subject Lines Land You in Spam?

This is a persistent myth that just won't die. The short answer is no, emojis by themselves don’t hurt your deliverability. Major brands use them constantly and land in the inbox just fine.

The problem isn't the emoji itself; it's the company it keeps.

Spam filters don't just see a 🚀 and block you. They analyze the entire context. A subject line packed with desperate-looking emojis, shady language, and all-caps text is a huge red flag. But a single, relevant emoji used to add a bit of personality to a clear subject line? That’s perfectly fine.

✅ This works: "Our Summer Sale Ends Soon ☀️"

❌ This doesn't: "🔥🔥🔥 FREE MONEY NOW 🤑🤑🤑"

Treat emojis like salt. A little bit enhances the dish, but dump the whole shaker in and you’ll ruin dinner.

What Should I Do If My Domain Gets Blacklisted?

Okay, first things first: don't panic. Seeing your domain on a blacklist is stressful, but it's almost always fixable. Your first move is to figure out which blacklist you're on and why. A tool like MXToolbox is your best friend here; it will check your domain against the major lists.

Once you know the reason—maybe you hit a spam trap, got a spike in complaints, or had a security issue—it's time to act.

Hit the Brakes: Immediately pause all of your email campaigns. The last thing you want to do is cause more damage while you're under scrutiny.

Find and Fix the Leak: This is the most important part. Get to the root cause. Scrub your list, secure your sending infrastructure, rewrite spammy content—whatever it takes to solve the problem that got you listed.

Request Removal: After the problem is truly fixed, go to the blacklist's website and follow their delisting process. This usually involves filling out a form where you explain what happened and what you’ve done to fix it.

Being honest and showing you've taken corrective action is the fastest way to get your domain back in the clear.

Ready to stop worrying about deliverability and focus on creating amazing content? Feather turns your Notion pages into a fully-optimized blog and newsletter, handling the technical details so you don't have to. Publish seamlessly and build your audience with a platform designed for creators. Start your free trial at https://feather.so and see the difference.